Trying to be consistent is challenging when you have five different classes with very different personalities. I'm trying to balance what each class needs while maintaining fair treatment across classes. I have to remember that fair does not mean the same treatment (something my mom always said growing up and I never believed.) I still have a sense that being fair means treating everyone the same. But that just doesn't work. So I'm working on seeing the difference between what is fair what needs to happen to help students learn.
I have three different beginning drama classes: one at the beginning of the day, one in the middle and one at the end. They have very different personalities and so in order to get them to be constructive I have to treat them differently.
My beginning period is pretty dead. It is early and they are not very awake. I also get a lot of late students in that class. It takes a lot of energy to wake them up and get them moving. I push them a bit more because they come in with such low energy.
My middle period is pretty reasonable, but has a few very big personalities that need to be kept in check. I need to balance letting them express themselves and not letting the class get out of control.
My last period has a ton of energy, which seems to be the trend for the last period of the day. They are creative and fun to work with. But they can get out of control and distracted very fast. With them it is about focusing the energy they already have.
Because of these differences between classes, each one has different rules. Last period does not get to choose their own groups, ever. I always choose performance groups to get them to know new people, but my beginning and middle periods get to choose their own groups for smaller group assignments. I tried that with last period a few times and it was a mess. They did not focus at all. So now I choose their groups all the time.
I also have to be careful when I take volunteers in my last period. I have several very enthusiastic students who always want to participate. I love it. But I noticed that others starting sitting back and not working because others would always volunteer. So now I make sure I am cold-calling people as well as taking volunteers. I have a similar problem in first period except that no one volunteers. So I have to make sure I am not always calling on the same people.
My intermediate and advanced classes are both performance based. But they have different rules as well. My intermediate class does not have a seating chart. That class gets along well and has formed a really strong sense of community. My advanced class however is cliquish and so I've given them a seating chart to separate the cliques and make them get to know other people. They aren't a fan, but it has helped break things up a bit.
I try to be consistent within classes, making sure consequences and rules stay similar. But trying to do it across classes doesn't really help anyone.